重新审视冲突:政策过程中去政治化的回旋镖效应

Conflict reconsidered: The boomerang effect of depoliticization in the policy process

Public Administration · 2018
被引 51
ABS 4

中文导读

研究发现政策制定者短期回避冲突的努力长期可能适得其反,以比利时安特卫普高速公路项目为例,去政治化可能暂时平息争议但最终加剧冲突,浪费公众参与和创造力。

Abstract

This article argues that the efforts of policy‐makers to avoid conflict in the short run can be counterproductive in the long run. Not only may policy‐makers fail to reap the benefits of conflicts when they try to steer clear, but conflict may actually increase rather than diminish. We study conflict through the conceptual lens of (de)politicization in the lengthy and highly contested policy‐making process over the multibillion‐euro ‘Oosterweelconnection’ highway in Antwerp (Belgium). An in‐depth media analysis of 739 articles is combined with data from 32 narrative interviews. We conclude that efforts to end public debate through depoliticization can have a boomerang effect, in which conflict disappears only temporarily, and that these efforts can ultimately increase conflict while wasting engagement and creativity. More attention to the productive aspects of conflict is needed in public administration literature and practice.

公共政策公共管理政治学政策过程