随身摄像头与警务:一项关于公民公开支持与真实支持的列表实验

Body‐Worn Cameras and Policing: A List Experiment of Citizen Overt and True Support

Public Administration Review · 2018
被引 36
ABS 4★

中文导读

通过列表实验测量公民对警察随身摄像头使用的真实支持度,发现社会期望偏差影响民意调查结果,决策者不应仅依赖公开民调。

Abstract

Abstract Police body‐worn cameras (BWCs) have gained popularity in recent years. However, many minimize the complexity of this transparency initiative and elevate the potential benefits. While BWCs can promote police accountability, they may also reduce citizen trust in police organizations. For BWCs to achieve win‐win solutions, police organizations should determine the level of citizen support for specific BWC practices. However, measuring citizen support presents several challenges. Social desirability may impact polling results, as participants underreport responses they perceive to be outside the norm. The authors employ a list experiment design to measure true citizen support for BWC practices. They find statistically significant levels of social desirability for police discretion in the activation of BWCs and for restriction of footage accessibility regarding suspects with mental illness. Decision makers should not rely on public opinion polls as a gauge of true citizen support for BWC use .

警务公共政策社会心理学透明度民意调查