政治中的欺骗者检测:进化与公民追究政治领导人责任的能力

Cheater detection in politics: Evolution and citizens' capacity to hold political leaders accountable

LEADERSHIP QUARTERLY · 2018
被引 13
人大 AABS 4

中文导读

基于进化理论,研究公民如何利用内在的欺骗者检测系统识别违反决策规则的政治领导人,并通过跨国调查实验验证这一机制,有助于理解公民的民主能力。

Abstract

The average citizen is often unable to distinguish and choose between political leaders according to their ideological profiles. Research using evolutionary theory shows that citizens instead turn to perceptions of procedural fairness concerning whether leaders follow basic decision-making rules such as passing policies without personal interest and displaying responsiveness to citizens' opinions. Some argue that this helps citizens “weed out” questionable leaders; others question citizens' ability to distinguish those following the rules from those who do not. To address this question, I build on psychological research showing that the mind possesses a natural ability, a cheater-detection system, enabling the detection of self-interested others who violate social rules. Introducing an experimental protocol from psychology embedded in cross-national surveys, I show that this system also operates when citizens evaluate political leaders, facilitating identification of leaders who violate basic decision-making rules. The findings advance our understanding of citizens' democratic competences and followers' cognitive abilities generally.

政治学进化心理学公共舆论民主能力