错误的马歇尔:回应阿尔弗雷德·马歇尔传记的马歇尔家族注释

The Wrong Marshall: Notes on the Marshall family in Response to Biographies of the Economist, Alfred Marshall

History of Political Economy · 2020
被引 5
人大 A-ABS 2

中文导读

质疑科斯关于马歇尔家族不诚实的说法,通过考证证明科斯引用的关键会面并未发生,马歇尔家族关系并非如科斯所述,对研究马歇尔及其传记的学者有参考价值。

Abstract

Professor Ronald H. Coase included his essays on Alfred Marshall in his book, Essays on Economics and Economists. Because of Coase’s standing as a Nobel laureate and professor of economics at the University of Chicago, these essays have been relied on by scholars, authors, and historians researching Alfred Marshall and the wider Marshall family, including Professor Peter Groenewegen for his seminal biography, A Soaring Eagle: Alfred Marshall 1842–1924. This research shows that the supposed meeting between Charles Henry Marshall, Alfred’s uncle, and Nehemiah Bartley on the Turon goldfields, on which Coase based his claims of a deceitful and self-aggrandizing family, did not take place. Alfred did know where he was born and was happy to say so. Alfred’s grandfather, William, was not a forgotten business failure. Alfred’s father, also William, was neither disliked nor ostracized by his family despite being cantankerous and possibly brutal. He and his wife Rebecca and their children, including Alfred, were embraced and supported by the wider family. Alfred was, in fact, a product of the family much as described by his wife, Mary Paley Marshall, and John Maynard Keynes. This does not diminish his accomplishments.

阿尔弗雷德·马歇尔马歇尔家族科斯传记修正