了解(按性别分列的)土地状况:调查受访者选择对衡量土地所有权和权利的影响

Getting the (Gender-Disaggregated) lay of the land: Impact of survey respondent selection on measuring land ownership and rights

World Development · 2021
被引 36
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

利用马拉维两项全国调查数据,比较不同受访者选择方式对测量农业土地所有权和权利的影响,发现仅采访最知情家庭成员会导致男性独占报告比例偏高、女性共同所有权比例偏低。

Abstract

Monitoring international goals on land ownership and rights relies fundamentally on the quality of underlying data, which, in the context of surveys, are directly impacted by how respondents are selected. This study leverages two national surveys in Malawi that asked households about household members’ ownership and rights of agricultural land, but which differed in their approach to respondent selection. Compared with the international best practice of privately interviewing adults about their personal asset ownership and rights, the analysis reveals that the business-as-usual approach of interviewing only a most knowledgeable household member on adult members’ ownership and rights of agricultural land leads to (i) a higher share of men claiming exclusive reported and economic ownership, and (ii) a lower share of women claiming joint reported and economic ownership. Using private interviews of spouses’ ownership and rights over the same set of parcels, the analysis also shows that when conflicting claims emerge, proxies for greater household status for women are positively associated with scenarios where women attribute at least some land ownership to themselves.

调查受访者选择土地所有权性别差异测量方法