矮胖且被低估?教师评估中儿童体型导致的偏见

Short, Heavy and Underrated? Teacher Assessment Biases by Children's Body Size

Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics · 2020
被引 9
人大 AABS 3

中文导读

通过比较教师主观评分与盲测成绩,发现教师对较矮和较重的儿童评分更低,且体重导致的评分差距无法用学生行为、动机或能力解释,可能源于教师偏见,进而影响学生未来数学成绩和兴趣。

Abstract

Abstract We compare non‐blind teacher assessments with blind national test scores in maths to examine teacher‐test score disparities by children's height and weight. Relative to test scores, shorter and heavier children are rated less favourably by teachers. This teacher‐test score discrepancy cannot be explained by the child's behaviours, motivation to learn or cognitive ability. Unobserved student fixed effects across subjects explain the teacher‐test score discrepancy by height, but not weight. Our analysis points to biased teacher assessments as the most plausible explanation for the remaining teacher‐test score gap by weight. We find harsher teacher assessments are associated with a reduction in both the child's future test performance and liking for maths 4 years later.

教师评估偏差儿童体型身高体重