凯恩斯、库恩与知识社会学:对Pernecky和Wojick的评论

Keynes, Kuhn and the sociology of knowledge: a comment on Pernecky and Wojick

Cambridge Journal of Economics · 2020
被引 3
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

评论Pernecky和Wojick用库恩科学哲学诊断凯恩斯被强行纳入瓦尔拉斯经济学的问题,指出其诊断本身存在矛盾,并建议采用批判理性主义哲学。

Abstract

Abstract Mark Pernecky and Paul Wojick use T.S. Kuhn’s philosophy of science to diagnose The problematic nature and consequences of the effort to force Keynes into the conceptual cul-de-sac of Walrasian economics. But their diagnosis is itself problematical in nature and consequence. It assumes the virtues of a pre-Kuhnian philosophy of knowledge that the Kuhnian meta-framework overtly discards. One way to eliminate the inconsistency is to recognise that Kuhn’s philosophy of science and sociology of knowledge function to immunise theories from criticism. Anyone who wishes to embrace a sociologically more critical philosophy ought to consider instead the philosophical attitude of critical rationalism.

凯恩斯库恩知识社会学批判理性主义