系上安全带还是捐献器官:加强安全带执法与器官捐献

Click it or give it: Increased seat belt law enforcement and organ donation

Health Economics · 2020
被引 3
人大 A-

中文导读

研究了加强安全带执法如何影响器官捐献数量,发现虽然减少了交通事故死亡人数,但也显著降低了来自交通事故的器官捐献,而对其他来源无影响。

Abstract

Laws mandating that individuals wear a seat belt have the presumed goal of reducing motor vehicle accident fatalities, but the prevailing view is that they may reduce the number of organs available. I provide a conceptual model identifying mechanisms whereby the law could either increase or decrease organ donation. Exploiting variation across states and time in the adoption of primary seat belt enforcement, I investigate these mechanisms and estimate the effect of the law on the supply of organs. The law increases seat belt usage and decreases motor vehicle accident fatalities, which translates to a sizeable reduction in the number of motor vehicle accident-based organ donors. In contrast, the law is not associated with changes in the number of organ donors from nonmotor vehicle accident-based sources and is robust to controlling for hospital-specific effects. The effects are concentrated within organs expected to be most negatively impacted by the seat belt. Although primary enforcement represents a net-gain to society in terms of lives saved, the negative impact on organ donation suggests further emphasis be placed on policies aimed at increasing the availability of organs.

安全带法器官捐献交通事故死亡率执法强度