作为认知现象的社会与科学失序,或政府膳食指南的后果

Social and scientific disorder as epistemic phenomena, or the consequences of government dietary guidelines

Journal of Institutional Economics · 2018
被引 22
ABS 3

中文导读

提出一个基于过程的科学模型,认为外部干预(如美国政府制定膳食指南)会扭曲科学的出版-引用-声誉过程,进而导致科学知识和社会秩序的失序。

Abstract

Abstract We begin with a process-oriented model of science according to which signals concerning scientific reputation serve both to coordinate the plans of individuals in the scientific domain and to ensure that the knowledge that emerges from interactions between scientists and the environment is reliable. Under normal circumstances, scientific order emerges from the publication–citation–reputation (PCR) process of science. We adopt and extend F. A. Hayek's epistemology according to which knowledge affords successful plan-based action and we employ this in the development of an epistemic theory of social order . We propose that external interferences with the PCR process have distorting effects on scientific knowledge and, thus, on scientific and social order more broadly. We support this claim by describing the history of the US federal government's development of standardized dietary guidelines for American consumers and its concomitant interference in the PCR process of nutritional science. We conclude that this interference contributed to social dis order in dietary science and beyond.

科学社会学认知论公共政策营养科学