你说了算:实验检验担任司法职务的激励力量

You Are in Charge: Experimentally Testing the Motivating Power of Holding a Judicial Office

Journal of Legal Studies · 2017
被引 24
ABS 3

中文导读

通过实验室实验排除了长期金钱激励和自我选择效应,发现担任司法职务本身就能激励人们克服社会困境,且这种效应源于履行职务期望的动机,而非对受害者的愤怒或同情。

Abstract

Apparently, judges’ decisions are not motivated by maximizing profit. Two explanations compete: there are long-term monetary consequences; conscientious individuals self-select into the profession. In a lab experiment, we rule out both explanations. Nonetheless, authorities do a reliable job of overcoming a social dilemma. Calling the authorities public officials or judges strengthens the effect. This suggests that the effect is not driven by anger or sympathy with the victims but follows from the office motive: the desire to fulfill the expectations that come with an assigned task. We test three extensions: When given an opportunity to announce an explicit policy, judges become less sensitive to the objective degree of reproach and more sensitive to their personal social value orientation. If judges are elected or experienced, they react more intensely to norm violations. Experienced judges are more affected by their social value orientation.

实验经济学司法行为社会困境动机心理学