The Impact of Graphical Displays of Pro Forma Earnings Information on Professional and Nonprofessional Investors' Earnings Judgments
研究发现，图形展示形式收益信息会影响非专业投资者的收益判断，而对专业投资者的影响则取决于判断的复杂性。
ABSTRACT: Regulation G (SEC 2003b) requires managers to reconcile textual non-GAAP performance measures (i.e., pro forma disclosures) to GAAP. Graphical disclosures also require reconciliation; however, neither the format nor the placement of the reconciliation is specified. We apply cognitive fit theory to argue that the influence of graphical information presentation formats is contingent on investor type and judgment complexity. Participants in our study viewed a simulated Investor Relations website for a large drug retailer and made judgments regarding current fiscal year earnings performance, earnings potential, and investment amount. We manipulated graphical (GAAP-only versus GAAP and pro forma) and textual (GAAP-only versus pro forma reconciled to GAAP) earnings disclosure content in a 2 × 2 between-participants design. We find that nonprofessional investors' current fiscal year earnings performance, earnings potential, and investment amount judgments are all influenced by graphical displays, which include pro forma as opposed to GAAP-only earnings information. Graphical displays of pro forma earnings information do not influence professional investors' current year earnings performance judgments; however, these displays do influence professional investors' earnings potential and investment amount judgments because they are more complex. Our results suggest a need to further examine the influence of graphical pro forma earnings presentation formats on investor judgments. Data Availability: Contact the first author.