Opacity, Credit Rating Shopping, and Bias
构建理性预期模型,研究发行人如何通过不透明接触和选择性披露信用评级,导致评级偏差和投资效率损失,并指出监管披露要求可提升社会福利。
We develop a rational expectations model in which an issuer purchases credit ratings sequentially, deciding which to disclose to investors. Opacity about contacts between the issuer and rating agencies induces potential asymmetric information about which ratings the issuer obtained. While the equilibrium forces disclosure of ratings when the market knows these have been generated, endogenous uncertainty about whether there are undisclosed ratings can arise and lead to selective disclosure and rating bias. Although investors account for this bias in pricing, selective disclosure makes ratings noisier signals of project value, leading to inefficient investment decisions. Our paper suggests that regulatory disclosure requirements are welfare enhancing. This paper was accepted by Gustavo Manso, finance.