Racial Discrimination and Street‐Level Managers: Performance, Publicness, and Group Bias
通过实验研究街头管理者(如学校校长)的种族歧视行为,发现公民绩效信息可缓解歧视,但组织公共性(公立vs特许学校)影响不显著,白人管理者歧视黑人公民,而黑人管理者因工作环境困难回复率低。
Abstract This article broadens our understanding of street‐level governance by examining how citizen performance, organizational publicness, and group bias moderate racial discrimination among street‐level managers (SLMs). We examine this topic with an experiment in which we requested enrollment information from public and charter school principals while randomly assigning a putative student's race and ability. As expected, SLMs discriminated based on race, and positive performance information mitigated this discrimination. Surprisingly, negative performance information also reduced discrimination. Turning to publicness, we find no evidence that less public organizations (charter schools) exacerbated anti‐Black discrimination. Finally, we show that White SLMs discriminated against Black citizens. However, Black SLMs worked in more administratively difficult settings and, perhaps as a result, responded at lower rates; thus, Black citizens were equally likely to receive responses from White and Black SLMs. Therefore, improving access to public agencies may require representativeness and support for SLMs working in challenging organizational environments.