政策不确定性下的最优制衡

OPTIMAL CHECKS AND BALANCES UNDER POLICY UNCERTAINTY

International Economic Review · 2021
被引 0
人大 AABS 4

中文导读

研究了政治制衡在民主制度中的利弊,发现当政治阶层能力中等且问责高时制衡不太可取,而在改革效果难评估且问责低时制衡总是可取的,并揭示了宪法陷阱的可能性。

Abstract

Abstract Political checks and balances are debated desiderata in the evaluation of democratic systems. We suggest a framework where the pros and cons of checks and balances are, respectively, the reduction of type‐I errors and the increase of type‐II errors in policy decision making. Political checks and balances are less desirable for intermediate levels of competence of the political class when accountability is high. In policy areas where the effects of reforms are harder to evaluate and accountability is low, political checks and balances are always desirable. Positive constitutional design reveals the possibility of constitutional traps, with politicians choosing less desirable regimes.

政治制衡政策不确定性决策错误制度陷阱