传播好消息与从坏消息中学习:公共管理者绩效信息使用的实验证据

Broadcasting good news and learning from bad news: Experimental evidence on public managers' performance information use

Public Administration · 2021
被引 13
ABS 4

中文导读

通过对514名丹麦公立学校管理者的调查实验,发现绩效叙事(下降或上升)不对称地影响管理者内部使用(学习与控制)和外部使用(问责与争取支持)绩效信息的方式。

Abstract

Abstract This article argues and shows that performance narratives affect how and for what purposes managers use performance information independently of other known drivers of performance information use, such as the external environment and individual intra‐ and interorganizational characteristics. Using a survey experiment on 514 Danish public school managers, we find an asymmetrical effect of “decline narratives” (declining performance) and “increase narratives” (improving performance). In line with expectations drawing on literature on negativity bias and blame‐avoidance, we find that “decline narratives” lead to higher internal use (learning and control purposes) of performance information. In contrast, “increase narratives” lead to higher external use (giving account and building support purposes) of performance information. Further exploratory analysis suggests that internal use is not affected by narratives when managers are skeptical of the performance measure. More skeptical managers are, however, willing to use performance information with an “increase narrative” for external use.

公共管理绩效信息行为公共管理实验研究