是表演还是配合:公民对公共组织低信任反应的分类学

Acting out or playing along: A typology of citizens' low trust responses to public organizations

Governance · 2021
被引 24
ABS 4

中文导读

本文构建了公民对不信任的公共组织的四种反应类型(顺从、回避、钻营、抵抗),作为经典退出-发声-忠诚-忽视框架的补充,并分析了这些反应产生的制度诱因。

Abstract

Abstract Working under the assumption that societal pockets of low trust in government are likely to proliferate, this introduction to the special issue on “governance in low‐trust settings” integrates insights from the Global South and Global North to analyze how citizens respond to formal rules and service arrangements of public organizations they perceive as untrustworthy. We develop a typology of low trust responses—submission, avoidance, gaming, and resistance—as a counterpart to the well‐established exit‐voice‐loyalty‐neglect framework. We argue that these responses follow from institutional incentives and most likely emerge where people feel the system is not fair or feel like their back is against the wall, and they have the resources to game or resist the system. This article seeks to advance theorizing on governance in low‐trust contexts and enable a better understanding of citizen responses that are inconsistent with the governance mechanisms and service provision in high trust contexts.

公共管理政府信任公民行为治理