作者回应:如果要说污名化,我们应该污名化不健康的组织

Authors’ Response: If Anything, We Should Stigmatize Unhealthy Organizations

ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCE QUARTERLY · 2022
被引 3
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

作者回应评论,重申研究目标,反驳替代机制,提供额外证据,强调研究有助于防止对心理疾病患者的污名化,并呼吁关注不健康组织。

Abstract

We appreciate the important academic discussions that our article (Kensbock, Alkærsig, and Lomberg, 2022) has initiated. Replying to the commentaries by Keyes and Shaman (2022) and Pierce and Rider (2022), we reiterate the goal and purpose of our research questions, including the use of a metaphor. We address theoretical arguments that a “normalization” or “matching” mechanism might account for our findings, and we present additional empirical evidence against these arguments. We address concerns about methodological decisions made and demonstrate that altering those decisions would have little or no effect on our findings and conclusions. In doing so, we reaffirm that the contagion mechanism that we proposed based on a large strand of prior research is the most likely one. Finally, we discuss how and why our study results can prevent (rather than increase) stigmatization of individuals with mental disorders. We encourage future scholarly and societal discussions to bring unhealthy organizations into focus and to develop interventions that prevent the accumulation of mental disorders in organizations.

组织行为学心理健康污名化组织健康