民主、专制与主权债务:政体如何影响全球经济外围的国家风险,1870–1913

Democracy, autocracy, and sovereign debt: How polity influenced country risk on the peripheries of the global economy, 1870–1913

Explorations in Economic History · 2022
被引 9
ABS 3

中文导读

本文检验了第一次金融全球化时期(1870–1913年)民主政府是否比专制政府借贷成本更低,发现民主反而与更高的国家风险相关,民主国家比专制国家多支付5.7%的债务成本。

Abstract

This article tests the influential democratic advantage hypothesis – that democratic governments have historically borrowed more cheaply than autocratic governments – in the context of the first financial globalization, from circa 1870 to 1913. We construct indicators of political regime types, then regress government bond spreads of 27 independent capital-importing countries on them. In contrast with the mainstream literature, the results suggest that democracies were associated with higher country risk. Our findings indicate that autocratic regimes had a significant advantage: democracies paid 5.7% more on their debt than autocracies, controlling for several financial and political variables. This gap is the equivalent of 35.4% of the negative effect defaults had on credit costs. Our conclusions hold when allowing for different definitions of political regime type and bond spreads. The correlations identified also find support in qualitative evidence, according to which creditors favored autocracies for being politically more stable than democracies.

政治经济学主权债务民主与专制经济史国际金融