“他是‘妈妈先生’”:1987-2016年印刷新闻中对全职爸爸描绘的文化矛盾

“He’s a Mr. Mom”: Cultural Ambivalence in Print News Depictions of Stay-at-Home Fathers, 1987–2016

Gender and Society · 2022
被引 5
ABS 3

中文导读

分析了1987-2016年美国94篇关于全职爸爸的新闻文章,发现报道聚焦经济精英、强调“选择”,但经济原因比全职妈妈报道更常见;污名化体验普遍,且随失业背景变化,反映了对男性养家规范的矛盾态度。

Abstract

Stay-at-home fathers challenge norms related to masculinity and gendered divisions of parenting roles. We conduct a content analysis of 94 print news articles about at-home fathers published 1987–2016 in the United States, identifying key themes and comparing results with our earlier research on news depictions of at-home mothers. We also analyze national trends in fathers staying home using Current Population Survey data to understand contexts in which articles were published. Articles were family-centric and disproportionately focused on economic elites, emphasizing their “choice” to stay home, but economic reasons for fathers staying home were described more commonly than in portrayals of mothers. Stigmatization experiences were pervasive in articles, appearing more commonly when staying home was reported as discretionary, but less commonly when staying home resulted from involuntary unemployment in recent periods. Portrayals reflect, reinforce, contribute to, and challenge father-as-provider norms, mirroring changes in masculinity norms over time and revealing cultural ambivalence toward at-home fathers.

性别研究社会学心理学家庭研究媒体研究