不止是隐喻:评估资源依赖的历史遗产及其作为环境复杂性理论的当代前景

More than a Metaphor: Assessing the Historical Legacy of Resource Dependence and its Contemporary Promise as a Theory of Environmental Complexity

ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT ANNALS · 2013
被引 161
人大 AFT50ABS 4*

中文导读

系统分析资源依赖理论在管理学文献中的使用,发现其虽被广泛引用但实质性研究不足,然而在跨领域应用中影响深远,其关于组织外部环境由多元利益组织构成的独特见解对当代组织应对复杂性挑战仍有重要价值。

Abstract

At its inception, resource dependence (RD) held the promise to become a robustly developed theoretical perspective. However, behind an ever-growing citation count, scholars—including one of its key architects—have asserted that RD no longer inspires much substantive research and now serves as little more than an appealing metaphor about organizations [Pfeffer, J. (2003). Introduction to the classic edition. In J. Pfeffer & G.R. Salancik, The external control of organizations: A resource dependence perspective (classic edition). New York: Harper & Row]. A systematic analysis of RD's uses in the management literature lends some credence to this assessment. However, our analysis also shows a perspective that has been broadly influential and well-supported in applications that cross multiple empirical domains. Moreover, this impact has been achieved despite the widespread neglect of what is arguably RD's most distinctive insight; namely that an organization's external environment is composed of other organizations with diverse agendas and interests. The complexity that arises from these competing demands represents an important challenge for contemporary organizations. As scholars begin to crystalize a research agenda around this theme using an institutional logics perspective, we suggest that RD's unique insights on the topic are the keys to unlocking its contemporary relevance.

资源依赖理论组织理论管理学研究制度逻辑