筑墙与拆墙:中层管理者的边界工作

Walling in and Walling out: Middle Managers' Boundary Work

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES · 2022
被引 30
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

通过对巴西一家审计公司的多地点民族志研究,揭示了中层管理者如何灵活操纵边界的可见性和渗透性,构建出障碍、门面、禁忌和幽灵四种边界工作实践,并展示了同一管理者可同时阻碍和促进跨界。

Abstract

Abstract Literature around middle management has highlighted the importance of intra‐organizational boundaries, focusing on the in‐betweenness and fluidity of middle‐managerial roles and practices. Yet, this literature has largely focused on the crossing of largely stable, monolithic boundaries, placing less emphasis on the plurality of emerging boundaries and the ways in which they are constructed. Focusing on boundaries as the outcomes of, rather than only as constraints upon, everyday practices, we conduct an ethnographic study across multiple sites of a Brazilian audit firm, examining middle managers' construction, maintenance and adjustment of boundaries. Drawing upon ethnographic fieldnotes and 155 formal interviews, our study reveals how middle managers fluidly manipulate boundaries' visibility and permeability to achieve specific purposes, and how different configurations of these elements generate various boundary work practices, which we describe as barricade, façade, taboo and phantom boundary work. Moreover, we show the dual orientation of middle managers' boundary work – both obstructing and facilitating boundary‐crossing – demonstrating that, in contrast to prior research, both orientations can be enacted by the same actor according to his or her purposes. By doing so, we contribute to scholarship exploring agency and plasticity as the key issues linking the existing literature on middle management with that on boundary work.

中层管理边界工作组织行为民族志研究