定性研究中广度与深度的平衡:通过多点民族志概念化表演性

Balancing Breadth and Depth in Qualitative Research: Conceptualizing performativity through multi-sited ethnography

ORGANIZATION STUDIES · 2022
被引 26
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

针对管理研究中表演性概念缺乏实证操作化的问题,提出多点民族志方法能同时克服研究广度与深度的挑战,并通过巴勒斯坦被占领土的案例说明其应用。

Abstract

While performativity, as a theoretical concept, has gained much purchase in the field of management and organization studies (MOS), there remains a dearth of empirical work operationalizing the idea. In this article, we argue that empirical studies on performativity in organizational settings have been scarce mainly due to two methodological challenges: (1) the problem of breadth, and (2) the problem of depth. In terms of breadth, to study how a cultural/symbolic construction becomes performative, researchers need to follow threads of meanings and practices that stretch in time and space beyond the scope of what most methodologies afford. In terms of depth, studying performativity requires an in-depth, contextualized understanding of how people live in and through the symbolic world, which few methodologies possess the analytical resources to unravel. We offer multi-sited ethnography as a promising methodological approach that has the potential to concomitantly overcome both challenges. Through a vignette of a study that one of the authors conducted in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, we illustrate how multi-sited ethnography enables empirical research on performativity in MOS.

管理组织研究定性研究方法民族志表演性