合格抽签的理性

The rationality of qualified lotteries

European Management Review · 2022
被引 10
ABS 3

中文导读

论文论证了合格抽签(随机选择)在制度层面可实现二阶理性,通过利用或扩大不确定性来提升决策质量,并比较了其与竞争性选择机制的历史应用与优势。

Abstract

A lottery (or random selection) is often considered to be irrational. However, a qualified lottery can lead to a second‐order rationality on an institutional level. The main idea is to make use of uncertainty, either by exploiting existing fundamental uncertainty or by deliberately enlarging uncertainty through lotteries. In both cases, decision quality may be enhanced by increasing diversity and risk diversification, by decreasing biases and noise, and through a strong disempowering effect by the shadow of uncertainty. The paper shows the different ways in which qualified lotteries have been used in history, analyses why this procedure has been forgotten despite its clear advantages, and compares it with competitive selection mechanisms.

经济学决策理论制度设计行为经济学