宏大挑战研究的未来:退休一个充满希望的概念并支持研究原则

The future of grand challenges research: Retiring a hopeful concept and endorsing research principles

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT REVIEWS · 2022
被引 100
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

系统检视管理学期刊中“宏大挑战”概念的使用一致性,发现其定义混乱且缺乏分析能力,建议退休该概念,转而提出一套研究原则来指导未来研究。

Abstract

Abstract Editorial notes in leading management journals have urged scholars to address Grand Challenges (GC) as an opportunity for producing knowledge that matters for society. This review explores whether current conceptualizations of GC support a productive path for management and organizational scholarship by guiding empirical inquiry, facilitating cumulative theory development, and informing practice. We systematically examine scholarly articles, calls for papers, and editorial notes published in management journals for consistency in how researchers use and define the concept of GC and the scope of associated phenomena and attributes. We find three prominent conceptual architectures in use: discursive, family resemblance, and phenomenon driven. The variety and incoherence of current uses of the GC concept and the lack of efforts to improve its analytical competence lead us to suggest its retirement. Instead, we propose building on the enthusiasm around GC research and using GC as a term to define research principles that collectively help align research efforts and improve theoretical development and practice. The principles we propose capture a genuine origin story for management research on GC.

管理学组织研究宏大挑战学术概念