问题顺序偏差在变化政治背景中的一致性

The consistency of question‐order bias in a changing political context

Public Administration · 2023
被引 2
ABS 4

中文导读

通过六项比利时大规模调查实验,研究问题顺序对疫情治理效果评价和信任度的影响,发现偏差在多次复制中一致,但改变信任问题顺序时效应方向会反转。

Abstract

Abstract Question‐order bias is a well‐known weakness of surveys commonly used in public administration research. However, most research on question‐order bias uses question‐order experiments that are relatively small, performed in one context, and rarely replicated. We carry out six question‐order experiments in six large‐scale Belgian surveys conducted during the COVID‐19 pandemic. All experiments vary whether the respondents see questions regarding the effectiveness of pandemic governance or trust in different actors first. Results show that question‐order effects are real and reasonably consistent across the high‐powered replications, despite the changing political context of the pandemic. However, the direction of the effects largely changes when we flip the order of the trust outcome questions in the last three experiments, which sheds light on an underappreciated point: question‐order bias also seems to exist within batteries of seemingly similar outcome questions.

公共管理调查研究政治学问卷设计