信任在美国区域经济发展中不起作用:信任文献的另外五个问题

Trust plays no role in regional U.S. economic development—And five other problems with the trust literature

Kyklos · 2023
被引 6
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

指出信任文献存在五个致命的方法论问题,并利用美国1972-2018年区域数据发现,经济产出与信任之间没有统计显著的相关性,质疑了信任对经济发展的因果作用。

Abstract

Abstract Economists have developed a vast empirical literature on how cultural traits like generalized trust affect economic output. Much of this literature finds a positive causal relationship between measures of generalized trust, as gathered by international surveys, and economic output. However, the trust literature commits five deadly empirical and theoretical sins that undermine many of its findings. From the quality of the survey questions and responses to the paucity of theoretical models used to explain how trust affects economic outcomes to the radically different results from experimental evidence and others, the trust literature is riven with poor methods and bad data. Even so, applying common methods used in the trust literature to regional level analysis in the United States during the 1972–2018 period reveals no statistically significant correlation between economic output and trust. Given our lack of findings at the subnational level, we find further evidence to be skeptical of the trust literature.

信任测量信任与经济产出信任文献方法论美国区域经济