专利侵权纠纷解决中的专利权人偏好会影响创新吗?

Can patentee preference in patent infringement dispute resolution impact innovation?

R and D Management · 2023
被引 4
ABS 3

中文导读

研究中国专利侵权纠纷中专利权人偏好行政裁决而非民事诉讼的现象,发现行政裁决与发明专利申请量正相关,表明其提供了适度的知识产权保护以激励创新。

Abstract

Evaluating the impact of intellectual property protection on innovation should include multiple perspectives, of which the impact of patent infringement remedies is an indispensable perspective. The two options for resolving patent infringement disputes in China include civil litigation (CL) and administrative adjudication (AA). Despite the fact that the judicial system has been emphasized as playing the leading role in intellectual property protection, patentees have shown a strong preference for AA since 2015. The general application of AA had been criticized by scholars. Does the patentee's preference bring inappropriate protection and stifled innovation? This study used regression models and 2008–2020 data on the choice of patent dispute resolution mode in China. The number of invention patent applications was the dependent variable, and choices for CL or AA were the independent variables. The choice of AA and the invention patent application were found to have a significant and positive association, implying that AA provides an appropriate level of intellectual property protection to incentivize innovation. Characteristics derived from AA should be valued and used as a reference to improve innovation policies.

知识产权专利侵权创新法律经济学中国