🌙

特洛伊木马技术:将刑事法律逻辑偷运进医疗实践

Trojan Horse Technologies: Smuggling Criminal-Legal Logics into Healthcare Practice

American Sociological Review · 2023
被引 30
人大 A+FT50ABS 4*

中文导读

通过分析美国药剂师在阿片类药物危机中使用处方药监控程序(PDMP)的现象,提出“特洛伊木马框架”,揭示执法技术如何改变医疗职业实践,导致患者被转出医疗系统而面临刑事法律风险。

Abstract

In the throes of an intractable overdose crisis, U.S. pharmacists have begun to engage in an unexpected practice—policing patients. Contemporary sociological theory does not explain why. Theories of professions and frontline work suggest professions closely guard jurisdictions and make decisions based on the logics of their own fields. Theories of criminal-legal expansion show that non-enforcement fields have become reoriented around crime over the past several decades, but past work largely focuses on macro-level consequences. This article uses the case of pharmacists and opioids to develop a micro-level theory of professional field reorientation around crime, the Trojan Horse Framework. Drawing on 118 longitudinal and cross-sectional interviews with pharmacists in six states, I reveal how the use of prescription drug monitoring programs (PDMPs)—surveillance technology designed for law enforcement but implemented in healthcare—in conjunction with a set of field conditions motivates pharmacists to police patients. PDMPs serve as Trojan horse technologies as their use shifts pharmacists’ routines, relationships with other professionals, and constructions of their professional roles. As a result, pharmacists route patients out of the healthcare system and leave them vulnerable to the criminal-legal system. The article concludes with policy recommendations and a discussion of future applications of the Trojan Horse Framework.

医疗社会学刑事法律扩张职业社会学药物政策监控技术