在实验中驾驭情境:“真实”、根源与原理

Navigating context in experiments: The “real,” the roots, the rationale

European Urban and Regional Studies · 2023
被引 10
ABS 3

中文导读

研究了非技术实验在实现结构性变革中的有效性,提出驾驭情境(结构条件、政治制度嵌入、生态社会未来想象)是关键能力,并以维也纳治理实验为例说明。

Abstract

Experiments are heralded as beacons of hope for transformative change. But how effective can ephemeral micro-interventions be in achieving comprehensive structural change? This question is particularly relevant for non-technological experiments that are typically more place-bound than their technology-oriented counterparts. We argue that non-technological experiments may very well be impactful endeavors, but that knowledge and reflexivity about their contexts are key capacities for realizing their potential. Based on the literature, we define three context dimensions: structural conditions, political-institutional embedding, and imagined eco-social futures. By empirically delving into Graetzlmarie, an impactful governance experiment in Vienna, we show how “navigating context” in all the three dimensions has been a key capacity for the experiment’s success. It enabled adapting practices, self-conceptions, and objectives to specific but varying contexts, herewith ensuring the experiment’s impactful realization. Given the uneven distribution of such knowledge among actors in transformation processes, we discuss what this implies for experimentation. We argue for coordinating actors that serve as knowledge brokers and intermediaries between institutionalized policy and planning and ephemeral micro-interventions to achieve eco-social transformation.

实验研究社会转型治理实验情境分析知识管理