怀特海的具体性错置谬误与所有以瓦尔拉斯-帕累托一般均衡理论为微观基础的货币-宏观理论的不幸无用

Whitehead’s fallacy of misplaced concreteness and the unfortunate uselessness of all monetary-macro theory micro-founded on Walrasian-Pareto general equilibrium theory

Cambridge Journal of Economics · 2023
被引 3
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

指出,以瓦尔拉斯-帕累托一般均衡理论为微观基础的货币-宏观理论犯了怀特海所说的具体性错置谬误,导致理论要么多余地添加货币,要么取消货币并扭曲概念,因此这些模型不科学,应被抛弃。

Abstract

Abstract Whitehead’s fallacy of misplaced concreteness (FMC) explains the ‘unfortunate uselessness’ into which all monetary-macro theory ‘micro-founded’ on Walrasian-Pareto general equilibrium (GE) theory has blundered. The FMC occurs because the misuse of the Walrasian-Pareto GE idealisation results in mistakes in reasoning when applied to monetary-macro theory. Consequently, theorists who employ the Walrasian GE idealisation as a foundation for monetary-macro theory are caught on the horns of a dilemma. Either money is appended when it is not required, violating the principles of monetary theory or money is abolished, (the ‘cashless limit’) and theorists are forced to change the meaning of words and economic concepts, in the process deceiving themselves and the reader. This paper provides a general explanation of the way all models based on the Walrasian-Pareto GE idealisation commit the FMC. There is no escape if the Walrasian GE idealisation is retained; models that employ it are unscientific and should be abandoned.

怀特海错置具体性谬误瓦尔拉斯-帕累托一般均衡货币宏观理论微观基础