风险因素作为事故原因:因果性标准、与事故关系的逻辑结构及解释的完备性

Risk factors as causes of accidents: Criterion of causality, logical structure of relationship to accidents and completeness of explanations

Accident Analysis & Prevention · 2024
被引 23
ABS 3

中文导读

本文论证了只有可通过道路安全措施改变的风险因素才能被视为事故原因,而年龄、性别等不可改变的人因不是原因,并探讨了事故原因集的完备性判定。

Abstract

The causes of accidents are studied in the belief that by finding causes, accidents can be prevented by removing or controlling their causes. It follows that the risk factors that have traditionally been regarded as contributing to accidents can only be regarded as causes if it is possible to alter them by means of one or more road safety measures. Risk factors are causes if their relationship to accidents can be changed by implementing one or more road safety measures influencing the risk factors. Hence, road safety measures that could have been implemented to change risk factors identified as contributing to an accident, but have not, are also causes of accidents. Many of the human factors that have traditionally been identified as risk factors for accidents, like age, gender, driving experience, expectations or involuntary inattention are not causes of accidents, because they cannot be changed by means of any realistic road safety measure. What cannot be changed (could not have been different) is not a cause. It is possible, both in case studies and in statistical analyses, to determine when a set of factors precipitating or contributing to accidents is complete. A list of road safety measures that could have been implemented is only limited by our creativity and imagination and will therefore never be complete.

交通安全事故分析风险因素因果推断人因工程