技术风险监管的多维偏好:政治信念、技术态度与国家创新文化的作用

Multidimensional preference for technology risk regulation: The role of political beliefs, technology attitudes, and national innovation cultures

Regulation & Governance · 2024
被引 11
ABS 3

中文导读

基于参与式监管概念,通过在美国、日本和德国的联合实验,研究了公民对自动驾驶汽车六种技术风险监管的多维偏好,发现普遍偏好制造商责任和严格安全监管,政治信念和技术态度影响较小。

Abstract

Abstract Building on the concept of participatory regulation, this study emphasizes recognizing the multidimensional character of citizens' risk regulation preferences. Using the case of autonomous vehicles, we specify six technology‐related risks: product safety, regulatory oversight, legal liability, ethical prioritization, data protection, and human supervision. We argue that differences in these multidimensional risk regulation preferences are shaped by citizens' political beliefs, technology attitudes, and national innovation cultures. To test these hypotheses, a conjoint experiment was conducted in the United States (1188 participants), Japan (1135 participants), and Germany (1174 participants) in which respondents compared hypothetical regulation regimes for self‐driving cars, varying alongside the six regulatory risk dimensions. The findings show a universal preference for increased legal responsibility of manufacturers and more stringent safety regulations for autonomous vehicles. Political beliefs and technological attitudes had minimal impact on these preferences. Although there were some cultural differences in privacy and ethical prioritization, no systematic differences were noted across countries, suggesting the possibility of finding common ground in standardizing risk regulations for self‐driving cars.

风险监管政治信念技术态度国家创新文化自动驾驶