行政邪恶与道德脱离:种族隔离时期南非的酷刑案例

Administrative evil and moral disengagement: The case of torture in apartheid‐era South Africa

Public Administration Review · 2024
被引 2
ABS 4★

中文导读

研究检验了行政邪恶理论中的道德倒置和班杜拉的道德脱离理论,通过分析南非真相与和解委员会中酷刑施害者的证词,发现施害者认为行为道德正当并推卸责任,但不支持责任扩散理论。

Abstract

Abstract Understanding how administrators can commit unethical acts is an important goal of public administration research. This article tests whether moral inversion, taken from Balfour, Adams, and Nickels' theory of administrative evil, can help explain torture, and also proposes and tests Bandura's theory of moral disengagement. It analyzes testimony from perpetrators of torture who testified before the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission in 1996–2000. The results support moral inversion, as perpetrators stated that they believed their actions were morally justified. The results also support displacement of responsibility, as perpetrators shifted responsibility away from themselves and toward actors above or below them in the chain of command. However, the analysis does not support the theory of diffusion of responsibility, as perpetrators did not take the silence of officials outside of their chain of command as approval, but instead anticipated their disapproval and tried to conceal their actions.

公共管理政治学心理学犯罪学人权