下一步是什么?在管理教育中(不)学习虚无和非事件

What’s next? (Un)learning nothingness and non-events in management education

MANAGEMENT LEARNING · 2025
被引 9 · 同刊同年前 5%
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

批判管理理论只关注事物的完整存在,提出基于表征、叙事和物质化三种负面过程的过程视角,探讨管理中的空虚与不完整性,并建议商学院和企业学习拥抱虚无和非事件。

Abstract

Most management and organization theories focus on the full existence and finitude of things. They deal with fullness and the full happening of things. Both organizing and managing mean fully producing something, doing something, or giving value to something. A good manager should follow what is happening and, even better, make things fully happen. But in everyday life, our managerial capitalism makes the world more and more impatient, problematic and incomplete, full of more and more holes, interruptions and voids that permeate experience. This is true emotionally (as frustration), narratively (as cliffhangers and suspense) and materially (as creative destruction scars our earth). In this essay for ML’s 55th anniversary, I argue for a process-oriented perspective on managerial emptiness and incompleteness based on three core interwoven negative processes–representation, narration and materialization. I explain how each of these processes contributes to a nexus of incompleting events at the heart of managerial processes. Paradoxically, I also suggest that different kinds of emptiness and incompleteness might be part of a more resonant experience of the world. Embracing patience, waiting, deep letting go, and the nuanced exploration of non-events within events could foster what Whitehead called a ‘culture of possibilities’. This perspective on possibilities – considering what might have been and what might yet be – could lead to a more harmonious relationship with nature. Finally, I encourage business schools and the corporate world to (un)learn nothingness and non-events in the context of the negative ontology discussed here.

管理教育组织理论过程哲学虚无本体论