From local markets to global legitimacy: A materialization perspective on technological innovation system's dynamics
提出以技术物质化定义地方尺度，通过法国生物精炼案例，分析地方与更广尺度如何通过功能互动演化，发现地方侧重技术物质化和市场形成，而更广尺度提供资源、终端市场和合法性。
The Technological Innovation Systems (TIS) literature has made considerable strides in exploring the spatial aspect of technological innovation dynamics over the past decade. Abandoning the purely national focus on TISs, scholars have theorized TIS dynamics simultaneously along multiple geographical scales, such as regional, national, and global. Yet, the conceptual and empirical insights on the local scale of TISs have been limited. This paper elaborates a local spatial perspective on TISs and elucidates how the local scale interacts with broader scales through structural couplings. We use technological materialization to define the local scale and illustrate our perspective with a case study on a local biorefining TIS evolution in France. Using event-history analysis, we explore how the local scale evolved through functional interactions both within and across the local and broader scales. The results reveal shifting configurations of TIS functions and their interactions at various scales in different periods: while the local scale was characterized by materialization of biorefining technology and local market formation, broader scales played more versatile roles by providing resources to, forming end markets for, and establishing the legitimacy of the local scale. Policy should promote biorefinery-internal markets through technological materialization and disseminate local success stories at broader scales. • A new spatial approach to TISs, centered on the local scale. • Technological materialization defines the spatiality of the local scale in TISs. • A case study on biorefining TIS from a primarily local perspective. • Strengthening legitimacy improves local actors' access to TIS resources. • Policy should foster local, biorefinery-internal markets of by-products.