Dispossession and beyond: Politics of rural land conversion in China's tourism villages
通过比较中国两个旅游村庄的土地转换案例，揭示农村土地征收如何产生不同的生计和分配结果，挑战了“土地掠夺”和“剥夺”的普遍化概念。
Across the peripheries of global South cities, projects to convert rural land for development purposes have brought dramatic impact on rural communities and environments. Many of these initiatives involve aggregating land, mobilizing investments, and resettling populations, with direct implications for villagers’ land rights and livelihoods. In existing studies, rural land conversions have often been examined through frameworks of “land grabbing” and “dispossession”. This paper argues for the need to go beyond these frameworks in conceptualizing the varied pathways and outcomes of rural land takings. It presents a comparative case study of two villages in China, whose land has been redeployed for tourism development. In one village, state-led expropriation led to the loss of land rights and the resettlement of villagers in new housing complexes. In another, villagers held onto land ownership and their property but saw intra-community inequalities amplified as residents were differentially incorporated into the tourism economy. By demonstrating how the nuanced mechanisms of land conversion could facilitate variegated livelihood and distributive outcomes between and within communities, this paper problematizes universalist conceptualizations of dispossession and calls for theorizing both “with” and “beyond” dispossession to account for the multifaceted dynamics of land development in global South contexts. • Theorizing with and beyond dispossession in rural land politics. • Comparative case study of two tourism villages in suburban China. • Shows how and why rural land conversion produces contrasting local outcomes. • Advances comparative research on land across North-South, rural-urban divide.