法庭决策中的身份认同

Identity in Court Decision-Making

American Economic Journal: Economic Policy · 2024
被引 11
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

利用瑞典法庭数据,发现被告若多一位同身份陪审员,被判监禁概率降低4-6%,刑期缩短10%,且社会经济背景与人口特征同等重要。

Abstract

We explore the role of identity along multiple dimensions in high-stakes decision-making. Our data contain information about demographic and socioeconomic indicators for defendants and randomly assigned jurors in a Swedish court. Our results show that defendants are 4 to 6 percent less likely to get a prison sentence if judged by one more juror belonging to the same identity-forming group. Moreover, they are given 10 percent shorter prison sentences. Socioeconomic background and demographic attributes are equally important for identity effects, and these effects stem from trials of longer duration and where the defendant is present in the courtroom.

身份认同司法决策陪审团量刑差异