糟糕的领导能有多好?领导者选择的机会成本

How good can bad leaders be? The opportunity costs of leader selection

LEADERSHIP QUARTERLY · 2024
被引 2
人大 AABS 4

中文导读

研究指出,在某些情况下,组织选择能力较差的领导者可能是高效的,因为将最优秀的人选放在领导岗位会带来机会成本,即他们无法再作为优秀追随者发挥作用。

Abstract

In many organizational settings, the person emerging as the group leader is not the best person for the job. The leadership literature provides several explanations as to why mediocre or even incompetent leaders exist. However, previous work builds on the premise that choosing a leader with limited skills is always a mistake. In this paper, we take a complementary stance and claim that—in some cases—organizations might select underperforming leaders because it is efficient to do so. Determining the leader within a fixed group of individuals is similar to allocating any other limited resource. Leader selection involves a trade-off, in that the benefit a person generates as a leader has to be contrasted with the opportunity cost that arises because the leader is (at least to some extent) no longer available as a follower. We identify cases in which it is optimal not to select the most competent individual as leader. Finally, we discuss how selection procedures need to be designed so that the most appropriate (but not necessarily the most competent) leader is chosen in a given setting.

组织管理领导力人力资源管理决策理论