谁在提问以及如何提问?调查模式和访问员性别对测量女性生活经历的影响

Who is asking and how? Effects of survey mode and enumerator gender on measuring women’s life experience

World Development · 2025
被引 1
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

在埃塞俄比亚农村极端贫困女性中实验发现,电话调查与面对面调查、男性与女性访问员对女性报告经历的影响总体相似,但最弱势女性在电话中更可能表达对家暴的不容忍。

Abstract

We explore the causal impact of survey design choices on measurement of outcomes about women’s experiences using standard questions that inform policy and research on women’s and girls’ empowerment. Among ultra-poor women in rural Ethiopia, we experimentally vary the survey mode (phone or in-person) and enumerator gender (male or female) for a survey module eliciting respondents’ beliefs about and experiences with physical safety, emotional well-being, and independence. We find that women report their experiences similarly to a female or male enumerator (for interviews conducted by phone) and they also report experiences similarly in person versus over the phone (for interviews conducted by a male enumerator). For the least empowered respondents, those interviewed by phone are significantly less likely than those interviewed in person to agree that domestic violence perpetrated by husbands against wives is justified under some conditions, suggesting that the privacy of a phone interview gives them an opportunity to state their objection. Our results suggest that phone surveys present a cost-effective means of collecting comparable sensitive data from women without altering respondent reporting, or with improvements possible in some contexts. • We experimented with methods for surveying women on sensitive gender norms in ultra-poor households in Ethiopia. • The gender of the enumerator does not significantly affect women’s responses, for interviews conducted by phone. • On average, women report similarly when asked by phone or in person. • However, the least empowered women seem more comfortable stating intolerance of violence over the phone.

调查模式访员性别女性经历测量电话调查