Secondhand social capital and idea quality in open innovation communities
研究了开放创新社区中，创意通过反馈获得的间接网络利益（二手社会资本）如何提升其质量，发现二手社会资本比传统网络约束指标更能预测高质量创意，且建设性反馈会增强这一效应。
Open innovation communities provide valuable opportunities for creators from diverse backgrounds to collaboratively generate and refine new ideas that companies can implement in new products or services. However, many submitted ideas in these communities are underdeveloped or misaligned with companies' expectations, raising questions about what drives high-quality ideas and, more specifically, innovation potential. We focus on the role of secondhand social capital, i.e., the indirect network benefits an idea accrues through feedback from providers who are themselves actively engaged with other influential ideas in the community. While prior research has explored ego-centric or first-hand networks, we extend this work by examining how an idea's position within feedback networks shapes its elaboration and innovation potential. We argue that feedback from highly connected feedback providers confers greater visibility, legitimacy, and alignment with community expectations, thereby enhancing the quality of an idea. Using data from an open innovation platform for vehicle design, we find that secondhand social capital significantly predicts higher-quality ideas. By contrast, traditional measures of network constraint (e.g., closure, structural holes) are not consistently and significantly associated with idea quality. Further, our analysis suggests that when feedback is constructive and encouraging, the effect of secondhand social capital is stronger. Our findings contribute to theory by identifying secondhand social capital as a key mechanism linking network structure and idea quality. More broadly, this research bridges micro-level creativity and macro-level innovation literatures by emphasizing feedback through secondhand social capital as a linchpin connecting idea generation and implementation in decentralized, collaborative environments. • In the context of open innovation communities, we introduce the concept of secondhand social capital • Secondhand social capital is the indirect network benefits an idea accrues through feedback providers engaged with other influential ideas • Secondhand social capital is associated with higher idea quality in terms of creativity and innovation potential • Secondhand social capital plays a more significant role than measures of network constraint in explaining idea quality • The influence of secondhand social capital on idea quality is enhanced when feedback from the open community is encouraging