Parallel learning loops in collaborative innovation: Insights from digital government
本文研究瑞士国家电子健康档案系统开发中的集体学习过程，发现政策导向学习与权力导向学习存在先后顺序导致技术缺陷，提出并行学习循环概念以改进创新成果。
The implementation of digital innovations in the public sector—such as Electronic Health Records (EHRs)—requires decisionmakers to engage in learning processes. This article investigates how collective learning processes unfold in collaborative innovation, focusing on the development of Switzerland's national Electronic Health Record (EHR) system. Building on policy learning and collaborative governance literatures, we conceptualize learning as comprising two interdependent processes: policy-oriented learning (focused on technical effectiveness) and power-oriented learning (concerned with political feasibility). Drawing on 39 semi-structured interviews and extensive document analysis, we find that the EHR initiative followed a sequential learning pattern—technical solutions were developed before sufficient political support was secured—leading to a politically endorsed but technically flawed implementation. The study introduces the concept of parallel learning loops to explain how simultaneous engagement with technical and political dimensions can improve innovation outcomes. These findings advance theoretical understanding of collaborative learning in digital government and underscore the need for institutional designs that support concurrent technical and political deliberation in complex innovation processes. • This study builds on theories of collaborative innovation to examine learning processes in public sector digitalization. • We argue that distinguishing between policy-oriented and power-oriented learning in the public sector. • We empirically analyze this link using data on the process of introducing an Electronic Health Record system in Switzerland. • Our results indicate sequencing of policy-oriented and power-oriented learning processse include failure. • The insights from this article generate important lessons for public sector digitalization.