在“灰色地带”追寻来源:档案泄露、档案众包与土耳其无企业档案的商业史写作

Chasing sources at the ‘Grey Zone’: Archival leaks, archival crowdsourcing, and writing business history without business archives in Turkey

Business History · 2025
被引 0
ABS 4

中文导读

本文探讨土耳其企业档案缺失或封闭对商业史研究的挑战,分析原因并提出利用替代来源(如科学企业史、灰色文献、私人传记)和档案众包作为解决方案。

Abstract

This article examines the challenges posed by the lack or closure of corporate archives in Turkey from the perspective of a business historian. It explores both the underlying causes of this archival inaccessibility – rooted in what I term ‘archival apathy’, characterised by absence, rupture, silence, and secrecy – and its implications for historical research. In response to these constraints, business historians in Turkey often resort to indirect strategies: they may gain access to archival materials by uncritically producing coffee‐table books, or they may rely predominantly on secondary sources due to the limited availability of primary documentation. As a methodological intervention, I argue for the use of alternative sources – such as scientific corporate histories, grey literature, and private (auto)biographies – as viable substitutes for formal archival records. The article concludes with a discussion on the potential of archival crowdsourcing as a collaborative solution for business historians working in archive-scarce environments, particularly in developing countries.

商业史档案学土耳其研究研究方法