释放、拘留还是监控?电子监控对被告结果的影响

Release, Detain, or Surveil? The Effect of Electronic Monitoring on Defendant Outcomes

American Economic Journal: Applied Economics · 2026
被引 0
人大 A-ABS 4

中文导读

研究审前电子监控(戴电子脚镣)相比释放或拘留对被告行为、案件结果和总成本的影响,发现电子监控虽比拘留省钱,但相比释放未能有效阻止高成本犯罪。

Abstract

This paper studies the effect of pretrial electronic monitoring (EM) relative to both pretrial release and pretrial detention (jail). EM often involves a defendant wearing an electronic bracelet, which aims to reduce pretrial misconduct at a low cost. Using the quasi-random assignment of bond court judges, I estimate the effect of EM versus release and EM versus detention on pretrial misconduct, case outcomes, future recidivism, and aggregate total costs. Results indicate that EM reduces overall costs relative to detention. However, EM does not prevent enough high-cost crime to justify its use relative to release.

电子监控审前释放审前羁押被告结果