评论:评价者人格重要吗?评价者大五人格与绩效评分关系的元分析

Commentary on ‘Does rater personality matter? A meta‐analysis of rater Big Five‐performance rating relationships’

Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology · 2026
被引 0
ABS 4

中文导读

本文反思了评价者人格(尤其是宜人性)如何影响绩效评分,并探讨了特质激活理论等新视角,对理解评价行为和改进评估系统有启发。

Abstract

Abstract In this reflective commentary, we revisit Harari et al.'s article ‘Does rater personality matter? A meta‐analysis of rater Big Five‐performance rating relationships’, published in the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology . The original study advanced a person‐by‐situation view on performance appraisal, demonstrating that rater personality traits—particularly agreeableness—influence performance rating scores, and that these effects vary across rating contexts. In this commentary, we reflect on the motivations underlying the original study and its contributions to scholarship on performance appraisal and person‐by‐situation interactions at work. We then discuss theoretical and methodological developments that create new opportunities for understanding why, when and how rater personality influences performance appraisal processes. In particular, we highlight how Trait Activation Theory, the Theory of Purposeful Work Behaviour and person‐centred methodologies can help to advance this line of inquiry. We conclude by arguing that understanding raters as people embedded in social contexts remains essential for explaining rating behaviour and for designing appraisal systems that are fair and accurate.

绩效评估人格心理学工业与组织心理学元分析