用排序投票对抗选区划分不公:美国多席位选区的实验分析

Combating Gerrymandering with Ranked Choice Voting: An Experimental Analysis of Multimember Districts in the United States

Operations Research · 2026
被引 0
FT 50UTD 24ABS 4★

中文导读

研究结合计算选区划分与多赢家投票模型,比较单席位与多席位选区(如排序投票)的效果,发现三席位选区能帮助独立委员会实现比例代表制,大幅压缩党派操纵空间。

Abstract

Blunting Gerrymandering with Multimember Districts How much can election rules blunt the power of partisan mapmakers? In the Operations Research paper “Combating Gerrymandering with Ranked Choice Voting: An Experimental Analysis of Multimember Districts in the United States,” Nikhil Garg, Wes Gurnee, David Rothschild, and David B. Shmoys study this question by combining computational redistricting with models of multiwinner voting. The authors compare single-member districts with multimember districts elected under rules such as single transferable vote (ranked choice voting), using algorithmically generated maps for the U.S. House of Representatives. Their results suggest that even modest three-member districts can help independent commissions reach proportional outcomes, sharply reducing the range of outcomes available to partisan gerrymanderers. The study also tests robustness under voter crossover and explores trade-offs involving geographic cohesion and within-party diversity. The paper points to election-system design as an operations research problem with direct democratic consequences.

选区划分选举制度排序投票政治学运筹学